Blog Post

The Best of Book Clubs

Aug 06, 2021

“A book read by a thousand different people is a thousand different books.” Andrei Tarkovsky

Reading may be a solitary activity, but it also leaves plenty of room for connection and book clubs are no modern invention. I've been a member of several, some which worked better than others


My worst experience was in a beautiful but stuffy private Mayfair members club where I felt wildly inferior and couldn’t decipher the conversation, let alone the book. I never went back, despite its seductive leather armchairs.


My current book club, on the other hand, has given me many happy evenings and excellent books. It’s been one of the few things that kept me going through lockdown (virtually).


I was curious as to what good book clubs have in common, so I spoke to the driving forces behind three, quite different, local clubs. I've shared their thoughts in a series of three blogs, the first of which you will find below.

Jacquie Marshall
Meet Jacquie →

The word connection came up in each conversation and I think that’s what it all comes down to. Good book clubs often seem to have space for a little bit of socialising as well as analysis. A respectful and relaxed space for people to give opinions on a topic they love can make local book clubs a positive community affair.


You also need open minded members who are willing to read books they wouldn’t have chosen themselves – that’s the beauty of being in a book club. But whilst encouraging you out of your comfort zone is one thing, it’s not about showboating – if Finnegan’s Wake is light fiction to you, that’s great, but read it on your own time. You won’t make a great book club by being too highbrow.


Read on for my first interview.


Jemina Talja

I started with the lovely lady behind my own local book club, my friend Jemina, about what she thinks has made it endure through the past few years, despite covid’s best efforts to scupper it. Jemina started the book club at the school gate, soon after her eldest started school. With members taking it in turns to host and cook, it’s a group of mum friends with similar aged kids and it’s been going strong for 3 years.


Why did you start your book club and had you been in one before?

I had been in one in Finland for ex-pats. Although I’m Finnish myself, I’d just returned home from living in the UK for years and was missing being abroad. Joining an ex-pat book club was my connection to all that. I was keen to start one here and school was an easy way to find likeminded people.


Your book club is loved by its members, how did you stumble across the winning formula with regards to the details?

Errr by accident really. I initially messaged about 20 people I’d met locally, thinking there wouldn’t be much take up and people would be too busy. When everyone started accepting, I was a bit nervous because I wanted to keep it low key in terms of entertaining. I think we’ve ended up at 13 and that really works. It’s still quite a lot of people to cook for but it’s just about manageable. And it means that even if a couple drop out on any evening, there’s still a big enough crowd for it to feel really fun. Anyone can suggest a book and we choose by vote and meet every 6 weeks.


And with a big number of friends how do you stop it descending into a party and forgetting the reason you’re there?

I don’t really! I often wonder if I should keep it more on topic but ultimately it just seems to work itself out. Not everyone manages to read every book, but there’s always a majority who have, and at some point, someone will remember to bring it up for discussion. Some evenings we’ve talked about books for most of the night, others not so much!


So what would you say to people who accuse you of being a wine club dressed up as a book club?

I would say we carry that title with pride! Our club is for busy women and mums, and it’s about socialising as much as it is about finding the time to read and love books again. And food as much as wine! We’re not serious and I think that’s largely why it works.

Most popular books?


Educated by Tara Westover



Girl, Woman, Other by Bernadine Evaristo



More Than A Woman by Caitlin Moran created the most conversation!

Least popular read?


The Electricty of Everything by Katherine May was not a popular read.

Check back in October for my conversation with the wonderful Haslemere Bookshop Book Club, and early in 2022 for my interview with Kate Cracknell, the lady behind the popular Haslemere Book Swap Facebook group.



As always our local Haslemere Bookshop stock a wide range of titles and can order any books they don't have in stock, please visit or contact them for all your reading needs! 

Related Articles

19 Mar, 2023
AppArt Art & Sculpture Exhibition at Prior’s Field School, Godalming
22 Jun, 2022
There is something for everyone at the 2022 Haslemere Fringe Festival! 1st - 3rd July, Lion Green
by Rosie Mulford 06 Apr, 2022
Coming soon, an exciting new venture for Liphook


Would you like to share your content?


Our focus is to grow this space to become a place of value where you can contribute, learn, teach, share & feel engaged in community life. Our vision is to create a space for the community and support you to create something amazing within it.

REGISTER YOUR INTEREST

Brought to you by


LATEST BLOGS...

31 Jul, 2023
Interview with Ian Rowley, owner of The Haslemere Bookshop The Haslemere Bookshop is an independent bookshop at the heart of Haslemere High Street selling new and second-hand books, and cards. Did you face any challenges when setting up the business? There has been a bookshop on the High Street for many years. When I took over the shop from Ronald Timms in 2014, I had no idea how a bookshop worked; fortunately the staff (all friends or family) did! Since then, through their hard work, the business has been transformed. Not only does the shop look very different but we are online, more community focussed and our second-hand book section rejuvenated.
04 May, 2023
Hamish Donaldson has been organising Haslemere Festival for 20 years, here we ask Hamish questions about the history & future of this wonderful biennial event.
Little Fish
14 Apr, 2023
Little Fish is on a mission to bring exceptional sushi and pan-Asian cuisine to food lovers in rural communities. Our ever-evolving menu has been crafted by Michelin-trained, multi-award-winning chef, Neil Witney – mastermind behind some of the UK’s top pan-Asian restaurants.
Show More
Share by: